The Human Fence

Wal-Mart, Vietnam, The Minuteman Project, Coyotes, Drug Caravans, Civil Homeland Defense, Freemasons, The Aryan Nation, Proposition 200, Silver Mines, Pat Buchanan’s Sister, The Grapes of Wrath, The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, Pete Wilson, Operation Gatekeeper, NAFTA, Naco and Nogales, Miracle Valley Bible College, Leprosy, Cazamigrantes, Red-Faced Septuagenarians, Nativism

The Human Fence

Ben Ehrenriech
Facebook icon Share via Facebook Twitter icon Share via Twitter

If you drive far enough south in Douglas, Arizona, you eventually hit the wall. You’ll pass through tidy avenues lined with new ranch homes and the stately old brick houses built for mining officials back when Douglas was a company town, when there were jobs here besides those offered by the Border Patrol, Wal-Mart, and the prison up the road. But this is the Sonoran desert, despite the lawns, and minitornadoes of red dust keep whipping themselves up in the streets and just as quickly dissolving. Then the avenues give way to a long, straight unpaved road, then a drainage ditch, and then the wall.

Constructed of adjoining rectangles of corrugated steel built to serve as landing strips for American planes in Vietnam, the wall climbs at least ten feet high for miles to the east and west, a ­rust-colored scar on the surface of the de­sert. When it passes through a wash, the landing mats are replaced by tall rectangular steel girders filled with cement, spaced just widely enough that water can pass between them, but not human limbs. Through those spaces, you can see into Mexico—more red dirt and skinny ocotillos, a thirsty-looking cow, a makeshift grave of piled stones and plastic orange ­flowers, the same blue sky.

If you linger here for more than a moment, the ­lenses on the Border Patrol camera towers will spot you, or you’ll trip a magnetic sensor or a seismic one, and one of the ­nearly 10,000 Border Patrol agents stationed along the 2,000-mile southern boundary will roll up behind you in a Jeep, lights flashing. If you are allowed to drive on, big-eared desert hares will leap in front of your tires, and more dust devils will rise and twirl to the right and to the left. Then the wall will block your view again until, without war­ning, about five miles east of town, it comes to an abrupt end, and nothing but a few sad strands of torn barbed wire remain to bi­sect the enormity of the desert.

It’s hard not to laugh out loud: all this mad fuss over so much nothingness. What are we so afraid of?


Jim Gilchrist’s home is a good nine-hour drive from the barren stretch of Arizona desert about which he has be­come so insistently concerned. De­spite this distance, Gilchrist has for months now been planning to erect a human fence along the im­aginary line separating the United States from Mexico, to station volunteers armed with binoculars, ra­dios, and often pistols at quarter-mile intervals in an effort to protect what they and Gilchrist understand to be America from all that it is not. Gilchrist is a retired CPA, and lives with his wife and two aging Chi­huahuas in a modest yellow stucco town house behind the walls of a gated subdivision in Or­ange County, California. Nearly all of the sur­rounding streets have Spanish names (Calle Cortez is not far), and even the car washes have Mexican-tiled roofs.

It is late March, and the Minuteman Project won’t begin for another week, but Gilchrist’s phone is already ringing every few minutes with calls from ABC News or Con­gressman Tom Tancredo’s of­fice. One of the Chihuahuas dozes on the couch in a mauve-and-cream-themed living room cluttered with ceramic angels, artificial roses, and framed New Testament verses. (His wife, Gilchrist explains, is the religious one.) A small man with hooded gray-green eyes, a quick smile, and a nervous laugh, he strokes the dog beside him and talks about being wounded in Vietnam on a dirt road just south of Khe San. “I think about that place every single day,” he says. A bullet struck his rifle, sending fragments into his face, head, shoulder, elbow, and arm. “We had nineteen men in our company killed that day. Their bodies were just laying in the trail.”

The thread of Gilchrist’s ramblings is loose and somewhat fray­ed, and before long he moves on to the last time he was in Arizona, about twenty miles west of Douglas, patrolling the border road with Chris Simcox, then the editor of the Tomb­stone (Ariz.) Tumbleweed, and, with Gilchrist, the co-founder of the Minuteman Project. On the other side of the barbed-wire fence, they came across three coyotes, as the guides who smuggle migrants across the border are called. “One of the guys must’ve been only seventeen,” Gil­christ says. “He needed braces;
I re­member that. They were friendly and everything, but they knew what we were there for. Our interpreter told them, ‘We’re not here to hurt you.’” The coyote an­swered, “Well, I got ninety-five people back there, and we’re coming in tonight.’”

“He even told us,” Gilchrist mu­ses with a laugh. “It was funny. It was somehow silly. Here we are on the other side of the barbed wire, and we’re giving them a gallon of water. We did everything but shake their hands. He said, ‘We need agua.’ So we gave them the gallon of water and they said thank you. I said, “De nada.” And the young one, he was about seventeen, he seemed to be so sincere.”

Gilchrist shakes his head in amazement at it, this simple interaction, stripped briefly of any shielding rhetoric. He doesn’t seem to know what to do with it, so he quickly returns to the comforts of rhetoric. Gilchrist’s colleagues along the Arizona border will later re­peat and repeat again the same arguments and many of the same phrases (“economic invasion,” “a na­tion of laws”). The degree of ra­tionality, nostalgia, and overt or im­plicit racism will fluctuate from Minuteman to Minuteman, but the basics will remain the same. By taking American jobs and bringing down wages, immigrants are de­stroying the American middle class. By taking advantage of government services, they are draining our wealth. They will bring us all down. They are criminals and terrorists. Most of this is demonstrably untrue, but it offers a tidy enough account to explain most of the dislocations brought about by the cur­rent state of global capitalism.

Then there’s “the stack of marbles”—Gilchrist’s semifunctional me­ta­phor for what’s replaced the old melting pot model, “where the cultures are banging against each other, each marble seeking dominance over the other marbles.” Be­ginning sometime in the 1980s, Gilchrist says, he began to feel “some­thing like a disorientation.” The country no longer looked the same. He began writing to his congressional re­presentatives to express his concerns about illegal immigration. His anxieties grew. When 9/11 came, Gilchrist was devastated. “That was the turning point.” He started spending a lot of time on the internet and read as much as he could.

Gilchrist came across an article about Chris Simcox in American Le­gion magazine. Simcox, a former el­ementary school teacher, had lived in Los Angeles until the fall of 2001, when he landed in the ­Western theme-town of Tombstone, Arizona, with a bad case of the post-9/11 freakouts. After the attacks, he told the Los Angeles Times two years ago, “For a while, I wouldn’t talk to anyone if they couldn’t recite the Pledge of Al­legiance.” He lost custody of his teenaged son after his ex-wife ob­jected to his signing the boy up for handgun training. He has since opt­ed for a calmer, revised version of his narrative: He packed up and took what he now calls a “vacation” to Organ Pipe Cactus Na­tional Mon­ument in southwest Ariz­ona. Simcox says he encountered large groups of migrants at every turn, even “drug caravans coming in.”

He tried to join the military, then the Border Patrol, but was told he was too old. He pitched stories to mainstream media outlets but found no takers. So he washed dishes for a while and acted in one of the local Old West shows as a bumbling gunslinger named Shame. He eventually found a job at the Tombstone Tumbleweed. Within six months he bought the paper and quickly trans­formed it into a mouthpiece for his anti-immigrant views. In Oc­tober of 2002, Simcox issued “a public call to arms.”

“Enough is enough!” the Tum­ble­weed shouted. “Citizen border patrol militia now forming!”

According to the Arizona Daily Star, two volunteers showed up to Sim­cox’s first training session, and twice as many journalists. Simcox was undeterred and now boasts that the group he founded, Civil Homeland Defense, is responsible for turning over more than 4,000 undocumented immigrants to Border Pa­­trol. (His critics claim that number is hypertrophically inflated.)

A few months after reading the American Legion article, Gilchrist heard Simcox interviewed on the radio. Intrigued, he checked out the Civil Homeland Defense website, then gave Simcox a call. He offered to travel to Arizona to lend a hand and to try to recruit some volunteers. He sent out a group email early last October and soon put up a website of his own, dubbing the effort the Minuteman Project.

Asked to fill in the blanks be­tween his reaction to the 9/11 attacks and the evolution of the idea for the Minuteman Project, Gilchrist leaps to his feet and races through a door in the kitchen into the garage. One wall is covered with framed black-and-white photographs of young men in military fatigues. “He’s my lieutenant,” he says, pointing to one photo, the pace and pitch of his voice rising with each word. “He was killed. These two were killed. He’s still missing in action. He died. He was shot in the back by a sniper. He’s dead. These are all friends of mine. This is me 36 years ago.”

Gilchrist hustles upstairs to his office. “9/11 comes along and I’m back there,” he says, meaning Vietnam. “I’m sort of back there all the time, but really back there.”

Displayed on the walls are a framed image of a man weeping, leaning against the Vietnam Me­morial in Washington, a drawing of Ronald Reagan in a cowboy hat, and a photo of a young Jim Gil­christ in Marine dress uniform. For days after 9/11, Gilchrist says, he couldn’t sleep. “I could hardly even walk,” Gilchrist says. “I re­member walking up and down the stairs real fast, up and down, up and down, telling my wife, ‘We’re going to go to war, we’re going to go to war, these kids are all going to get killed, our nephew Russell, he’s gonna get drafted, we’re going to war!’”

And that’s it: that’s as rational an ex­planation as it is possible to draw from Jim Gilchrist on the source of his obsession with the border. He talks more, for hours more, spinning off the usual lines about the burden undocumented immigrants put on the hospitals and how even traffic is worse, but the only answer he supplies that makes even the briefest solid sense is that confession of flashback psychosis, raw pa­nic, insomniac fear.


By 9 a.m. on April 1, two news trucks are already idling in the dirt parking lot beside the old Masonic lodge in Tombstone. Three more are parked across the street. It was here, in Schieffelin Hall, 122 years ago al­most to the day, that the residents of Tombstone gathered to gripe about the military’s failure to protect white settlers from Apache raiders. A posse of “Tombstone Rangers” set out on horseback and, failing to find any hostiles, fired blindly at members of a pacified tribe, then hightailed it back to Tomb­stone. Fortunately for all, every bullet missed.

The settlers’ fears have hardly abated though the Apaches are long gone. At this hour not many cow­boys can be seen either, even in Tombstone, where at any given mo­ment a good percentage of the local population is dressed as Doc Holliday or Calamity Jane. Twenty Minutemen are scattered about the lot, talking to the cameras about the need to seal the border before the Mexicans steal every last job. Most are potbellied, mustached men on the far side of middle age wearing camouflage baseball caps and holstered sidearms. The guns, a nasty local history of vigilante violence, and the fact that the Aryan Nation website listed the Minuteman Project as a featured “White Pride Event,” have been enough to get a lot of people worried that someone, be it Minuteman or mi­grant, might get hurt, and the an­xiety has seeped into the news­papers and television news shows. But there are so few Minutemen around this morning that the re­porters, who for the moment outnumber them about four to one, are beginning to grumble that the whole thing may be an elaborate April Fool’s gag de­signed to de­monstrate the gullibility of the press.

Sue Voss, a small permed wo­man in a denim shirt, struggles to light a cigarette in the wind. She’s a retired phone company technician from Tucson and is here, she says, be­cause she’s afraid of who and what might slip across the border when the government’s not watching. She had long been concerned about illegal immigration, but “September 11 was the kicker.”

She got involved with the ef­fort to pass Proposition 200, the so-called “Protect Arizona Now” initiative, a steroidally enhanced knock­off of California’s Proposition 187 that not only denies most government ser­vices to noncitizens but re­quires state employees to report un­doc­umented immigrants. It was ap­proved last fall by 56 percent of Arizona voters. Like many of her col­leagues, Voss does not think that the connection between fears of terrorist attacks and the desire to cut off benefits to immigrants re­quires any special explanation.

Late last year, Voss heard about Simcox and Gilchrist’s call for all patriots to descend on southern Arizona throughout the month of April to “surprise ILLEGAL im­migrants on trails heading north” and “suggest” that they “sit and wait for USBP… to come and pick them up.” Voss first volunteered a few months ago and has been coming down to Tombstone to help out with preparations ever since. “I am terribly proud to be part of this movement,” she says with a shy, earnest smile. “I think you’re seeing true America here.”

Several dozen reporters mill about, sticking microphones at a few white men with guns on the edge of a dusty parking lot packed with SUVs. Of course she’s right.

Tombstone was never much of a town. It sits in a particularly drab patch of desert on top of a history no more colorful or violent than that of most other Western towns. There were silver mines at one point, but since the late 1920s Tomb­stone has been skating by on a mythic version of Western ­his­tory, a tourist-friendly monument to a past that never was. Allen Street, the main drag, is a full-scale clapboard-and-stucco model of every eight-year-old’s Wyatt Earp fantasy, complete with costumed gun-toting baddies and “authentic Indian collectibles.” Genuine buzzards circle overhead.

By early afternoon, the Mi­nute­men have locked themselves inside Schieffelin Hall. A small group of protesters keeps the re­porters company outside. They wave hand-lettered signs that read “You’re the immigrant” and “Who’s illegal, Pilgrim?” Black-hatted Arizona Ran­gers guard the doors.

Inside, about a hundred Mi­nutemen sit stiffly on wooden ben­ches. Most are male, and almost all are white. Jim Gilchrist is standing at the front of the hall, squeezed into a tight tan suit that makes his head look like an accident visited upon his shoulders. Simcox is a few feet away, pacing the aisle with a vi­deo camera. Forty-four, goateed, and handsome in an aw-shucks sort of way, he purses his lips and squints with a studied Lee Marvin in­tensity.

Gilchrist blushes as the Minutemen applaud, then introduces the first speaker: Bay Buchanan, Pat’s sister. She addresses President Bush, who is not here. “You have failed us. You have failed our children. You are allowing criminals to come across this border, terrorists, drugs. Mr. President, you have failed America.”

The Minutemen whistle and stamp their feet. Tom Tancredo is next, the congressman from Colorado who is apparently hoping a po­litical career built on immigrant-bashing will land him in the White House. (He’s been visiting Iowa and New Hampshire lately, and will soon splash his way into the news by declaring that in the event of any major terrorist attack on American soil, the U.S. should bomb Mecca.) Tancredo is a tan, smooth-voiced man with neatly trimmed gray hair. He tells the Minutemen they are “American he­roes” and reassures them that, de­spite appearances to the contrary, “You are not a small group. There are literally hundreds of millions of Americans who feel as we feel.”

If Tancredo is overstating the case, he’s not entirely off. This may be a media stunt, but there’s something very real behind it, one of the periodic tides of nativism that washes over American politics whenever the economy sinks, bolstered this time by a huge and un­healthy dose of al Qaeda nuke-in-a-backpack hy­sterics. Copycat ver­sions of Arizona’s Proposition 200 are in the works in at least twelve other states, some as far from the border as Washington and Virginia. In the first three months of 2005, the white supremacist Na­tional Alliance went on a pam­phleting spree, leaving racist and anti-immigrant literature on lawns and doorsteps in fourteen states from California to New Jersey. In late March, they hit Douglas, ­Sierra Vista, and Tombstone, warning that “Non-whites are turning America into a Third World slum.” Last year, Samuel P. Huntington, riffing off such dodgy old tropes as the Jewish Question and the Negro Problem, published an essay titled “The Hispanic Challenge” (which became a section of his book Who Are We?: The Challenge to Am­erica’s National Identity), ex­pressing a ra­cially insular white na­tionalism with as­tounding candor. (“There is no Americano dream,” he concluded. “There is only the American dream created by an Anglo-Protestant society.”) Still more worryingly, he was taken seriously.

So the sound of stamping feet that accompanies Tancredo’s ovation is more than a little chilling. The effect is only magnified by Chris Simcox’s closing remarks. He speaks in a surprisingly gentle voice, stressing the importance of the “S.O.P.,” the ten-point Standard Operating Procedure he has ­drafted, which goes over everything from staying sober while on duty (point two) to picking up your trash (point nine). “We are going to be held accountable to the letter of the law in every way imaginable,” Simcox says. “You must show the greatest restraint.”

Before sending his men off to take up their posts along the border and protect the homeland from everything outside it, Simcox ends on an ominous note. He narrows his eyes and speaks very slowly. “The government cannot allow this to succeed,” he says. “The agent provocateur is out there. Maybe even in this room.”

The Minutemen stand. They clap and hoot and stamp some more.


“In the West there was a panic when the mi­grants multiplied on the highways,” John Steinbeck wrote in 1939. “Men who had never been hungry saw the eyes of the hungry. Men who had never wanted anything very much saw the flare of want in the eyes of the mi­grants. And the men of the towns and of the soft suburban country gathered to defend themselves; and they reassured themselves that they were good and the invaders bad, as a man must do before he fights.” Of course The Grapes of Wrath was about migrants from Oklahoma, not from Mi­choacán and San Salvador. Long before the Okies left the Dustbowl, fear of outsiders had a well-established pedigree. But there is nothing timeless in the most recent outbreak of xenophobia. This current rash belongs to us alone, to this un­steady moment of empire in crisis and slippery transnational economics.

Until 1875, no federal law ex­isted restricting immigration to the United States. A law drafted that year kept out felons and Chinese women, and another in 1882 ex­cluded the men. It was only at that point that America began to notice its southern boundary, and then only out of fear that the Chinese might sneak in through Mexico. The Border Patrol wasn’t founded until 1924, and be­fore 1929 it ­wasn’t even a crime to circumvent border authorities and slip into the U.S.: the concept of the “il­legal” immigrant did not exist.

While the rhetoric of nativism has hardly shifted a comma in a century and a half—the Irish, the Chinese, the Italians, the Mexicans, they’re taking all the jobs, they’re criminals and drug-runners, they’re corrupting our culture—its current manifestation, with its obsessive focus on the southern border, ­didn’t begin to take form until the mid-1970s and early 1980s, when downturns in the Mexican economy and wars in Central America sent a new wave of migrants north. Xenophobia has been rolling ever since, fading in prosperous years, blooming in bad times.

Thus the recession of the early ’90s brought us Buchanan for Presi­dent, Pete Wilson, and Proposition 187. In 1993, in what came to be known as Operation Hold the Line, Silvestre Reyes, then the Border Patrol chief in El Paso, be­gan concentrating agents in the ur­ban center of his jurisdiction and there­by dramatically reduced the num­ber of crossings between El Paso and Ciudad Juarez. (Reyes re­tired from the Border Patrol soon af­ter to run for Congress. He won.) The next year, the Clinton administration laun­ched Operation Gatekeeper, which poured resources into securing the border in urban sections of San Diego County. Feeling the pinch on both sides, mi­grants have increasingly been forced to cross through more isolated and inhospitable areas. Most cross through the Arizona desert. In 2004 the Border Patrol arrested nearly half a million immigrants crossing the 261-mile border of its Tucson sector—more than in all the other border states, both north and south, combined. In 1995 not a single migrant was found dead by Border Patrol in Arizona. Since then, more than 3,600 people have died crossing into the United States from Mexico.

No system functions without a certain degree of inefficiency, a calculable quantity of waste. That holds true for the massive global cir­cu­latory system of migratory des­pe­ration that sends Pakistanis to Du­bai, Ethiopians to Rome, Bur­mese to Bangkok, Turks to Berlin, and Mexicans and Central Americans to garment factories in Los Angeles, poultry plants in Tennessee, tomato fields in Florida, res­taurant kitchens, construction sites, suburban lawns, and cribsides from Seattle to the Carolinas. And it is one of the strange ironies of our time that, as Jennifer Allen, an immigrant-rights activist based in Tucson, puts it, “the borders are more open now than they ever have been. With the passage of NAFTA and other subsequent side agreements, capital goes back and forth, goods go back and forth, services go back and forth. The only way that the border is closed right now is for workers.”

For the moment, at least, it suits no one in power to change that. American politicians can squeeze political capital from the latest crisis at the border, mouthing the rhetoric of homeland security and the war on drugs while making sure that corporate agriculture and in­dustry have a reliable influx of cheap, easily replaceable laborers. (Last fall, the head of the Western Growers Association complained to Border Patrol that rigorous en­forcement at a Yuma highway checkpoint was keeping lettuce pickers from the fields. The checkpoint was promptly closed.) The Mex­ican government gets a convenient escape valve to let off the political pressures that accompany so much poverty, not to mention the benefit of the remittances wired by migrant workers to their families at home, which in 2003 sur­­passed the revenue Mexico earned from oil.

Until about five years ago, there was no border wall in Douglas, just a tattered chain-link fence with holes big enough that trucks could (and sometimes did) drive through them. Today, Douglas often feels like an occupied city. In some parts of town and at some times of day, every third vehicle you pass on the road is a white and green Border Patrol Jeep, Humvee, pickup truck, or Ford SUV. They have a shiny new $28 million station just outside of town, and in recent years have been able to count on a steadily growing budget for personnel, fencing, helicopters, and a multitude of high-tech toys. Walls have gone up in the other border towns too, slicing neat steel lines through the perimeters of Naco and Nogales, and if Border Patrol has its way, they will carve a corrugated barrier along the entire length of the state.


The Minutemen’s first trophy walked into their hands on the evening of March 31, hours before the project officially began, on the grounds of the Miracle Valley Bible College in Palominas, forty minutes southwest of Tombstone. It was there that many of the Minutemen were lodging, put up for a small fee by Miracle Valley’s current proprietor, a Pentecostal mi­nister na­med Mel­vin Harter. Built half a century ago by the evangelical preach­er Asa Al­onso Allen—who was said to be able to change the dollar bills in his po­cket into twenties through the power of pra­yer alone—Miracle Val­ley briefly ca­ptured national headlines in 1982. An Af­ri­can-American holiness congregation had moved down from Chicago three years earlier and found the lo­cals less than welcoming. Pa­ranoia built on both sides, culminating in a shootout between parishioners and police that left two people dead and se­ven wound­ed.

Smoking a cigarette in the Bi­ble College parking lot, bats diving through the night air above his head, Jim Gil­christ talks about the young Guate­malan migrant who, lost and alone in the desert at night, saw from afar the illumin­ated cross glowing on the roof of the Miracle Valley chapel. He hadn’t eaten in three days and walked toward the cross in search of Christian charity. He found the Minutemen. They gave him a blanket, cup­cakes, Sni­ckers bars, and a quart of water. “He said ‘thank you’ in English as he got into the Border Patrol truck,” Gilchrist says proudly.

Not everyone has been so lucky. One morning in January 2003, José Rodrigo Quiroz Acosta stepped onto a highway in Douglas and flagged down a pickup truck. He had been walking for days and was ready to surrender himself to the mercy of strangers. The truck happened to be driven by Roger Barnett, a Douglas rancher who owns the local propane and towing businesses. When Quiroz ap­proached to ask for water, Barnett allegedly opened the tailgate of his truck, releasing two German shepherds. While the dogs were biting Quiroz, Barnett allegedly grabbed him by the hair and punched him re­peatedly in the face and head. Eventually he called Border Patrol, and Quiroz was dragged off and deported.

The Cochise County Sheriff pressed no charges against Roger Bar­nett for assaulting José Quiroz. Nor has he been charged in the dozens of other cases in which Mexican nationals allege they were de­tained or abused by Barnett, who has become an iconic figure in the anti-im­migration mo­vement. Tom Ta­ncredo, in front of Congress no less, has called Bar­nett a “ho­meland hero.” Well be­fore the ar­rival of the Minutemen, Ba­r­n­ett’s reputation had made Co­chise Cou­nty (named for the de­feated Apache chi­ef) a magnet for ex­tremist border ac­tiv­ists.

In 2000, Jack Foote and Casey Ne­thercott, the gun-�crazy leaders of the now largely de­funct anti-im­mig­rant group Ranch Rescue, launched “Op­­eration Raven,” their first paramilitary ex­ercise in the county. It mostly in­volved dressing up in khaki fatigues and toting weapons on ranches around Douglas. Op­erations Owl, Hawk, and Thunderbird followed. (Participants received merit-badge-like “mission patches” as sou­venirs.) Chris Simcox, of cou­rse, showed up in late 2001, and in 2002, onetime Proposition 187 spo­kesman Glenn Spencer emigra­ted from the San Fer­nando Valley to Cochise ­County, where he laun­ched his own group, American Bor­der Patrol. He lives just 1,100 feet from the ­border, surrounded by fences and ground sensors in a fully wired prefab home from which he maintains two websites and dispatches young men on ATVs into the mountains to broadcast live infrared video footage of border crossers over the internet.

None of Barnett’s admirers work together or even get along, but they walk the same ideological trails and are joined by a tendency to get in trouble with fire­arms. Foote was arrested last year on weapons charges, and Ne­thercott served five months in fe­deral prison after a standoff with FBI agents in the parking lot of a Douglas Safeway in which one of his comrades was killed. He is now serving a five-year sentence in a Texas jail on a separate charge. Simcox is on probation for concealing a loaded pistol on na­tional parkland. And Spencer was on probation for most of last year—he pleaded guilty last January to endangerment charges after firing a rifle into his neighbor’s garage. He received a year’s probation. He had heard noises coming from his backyard, he told the Sierra Vista Herald at the time. In an unusual moment of con­trition that could one day serve as an epitaph for the entire nativist movement, Spencer summed up the situation: “I thought I was acting in self-defense.”


“Forget about WMDs,” says Rick Biesada, nodding knowingly at the sagging barbed wire strung a few yards away. “It’s nothing for one of these guys with a communicable disease to come ac­ross the border.” Mexicans, confides Biesada, are bringing “all types of social diseases,” from chlamydia to syphilis. “But the frightening thing is the leprosy.”

Today is April 3, the first official day of the Minutemen’s border watch. A Vietnam vet with a tough Chicago accent and Semper Fi tattooed on his tricep, Biesada shares a lookout post with the brothers Thatcher, Richard, and Robert, tall and short. The three men stand listlessly in the dirt. Ro­bert’s thirteen-year-old-son sits beside them, glum and sheepish in a low folding chair. The Thatchers silently scan the horizon to the south. They are among the 857 regi­stered Minutemen that Simcox and Gilchrist will claim actually showed up to volunteer. That number may even be accurate, though there never ap­pear to be more than about 150 pre­sent at any one time.

They will not, as originally plan­ned, “surprise illegals” and make them wait for Border Patrol. Ap­parently realizing that such tactics could constitute unlawful im­prisonment, Simcox and Gilchrist chose to implement a strict “no confrontation” policy: Minutemen are instructed to do nothing more than sit tight and call the Border Patrol if they spot any migrants.

There aren’t many to spot. The Mexican government and human rights groups have been working for weeks to get the word out, telling would-be border crossers to avoid the twenty-three-mile stretch that the cazamigrantes (migrant hunters) plan to stake out. (In fact, be­tween two locations—here along the border road near Naco, and the highway at the base of the Huachuca mountains south of Sierra Vista—they barely cover five miles.) And the Minutemen are hard to miss. They make no attempt to hide themselves. Flags wave from their antennae, and their pick­up trucks shine like a line of mir­rors in the sun.

Biesada owns a small trucking company and blames undocu­mented workers for wrecking the unions in Chicago for “diluting our sovereignty” and for being criminals. And lepers. The Thatchers are roofing contractors from Huntington Beach, California. The taller one says that immigrant labor has driven wages down, making it hard for contractors who only hire citizens to compete. The shorter Thatcher recalls southern California in the ’60s. “You wouldn’t be­lieve how good it was when I was a kid,” he says. “It was about the best place you could live.”

Now, Thatcher says, anger rising in his voice, “They run out their tamale carts like they do in Ti­juana. I call the police and they won’t do nothing about it. It’s em­barrassing. It’s just not right.”

It gets worse. “My brother, one day he walked out, and what was going on? A Mexican guy was going to the bathroom right in the middle of his lawn!” Thatcher bends at the knees, squatting in illustration. His face goes red with outrage. “This is supposed to be our country!”

Biesada jumps in and goes on for a while about the “nanny state,” unjust domestic violence laws, and how there’s no real patriotism anymore. He goes on long enough that the Thatchers begin peeking through their binoculars again.
I get ready to move on to the next out­post down the line, but before
I can take a step away, Biesada blurts, “I banged Hillary in 1967!”

He gives me a copy of his memoir, a self-published paperback titled Angry White Male and the Horse He Rode In On. On the cover, a drunk-looking Biesada sits perched on a Harley. And there it is, on page 64: “She whispered something about being Hillary from Park Ridge,
like it was supposed to mean something, but to me she was just another score.”

He signs the title page: And Justice For All.


Standing alone beside his pickup truck on the shoulder of Highway 92, Jim points his binoculars into the dry foothills of the Coronado National Forest. “We’re eyeballing a possible smuggler,” he says. An affable general contractor with bright eyes and a squirrel-gray beard, Jim asks me not to print his full name because he fears reprisals, he says, from the Salvadoran street gang Mara Salvatrucha. He points to a pass in the hills to the west. “This is one of the hottest spots in the nation for feeding hard drugs into the United States of America.”

More reliable sources than Jim re­­port that mainly marijuana comes through here, but no matter. Early this morning, Jim saw a man park his truck down the road and hike up into the na­tional forest car­ry­ing a large ba­ckpack. Hardly un­usual behavior, but, Jim says, squi­nting tightly, “We suspect him of being a resupplier.” Also this morning, “a lady with Arizona plates” stopped her car, Jim says, dropped a few McDonald’s bags and water jugs on the shoulder, and drove off. “We took them into our camp and they were still warm, so hell, we went ahead and ate them and drank the water. How is that for an insult?”

Asked if he doesn’t worry about migrants dying of thirst, Jim scoffs. “We don’t care—these are narco-druglords! These are traf­fickers! They’re killing people by the millions in the cities.”

A car and a truck roll up and three grey-haired men get out, among them Joe McCutchen, a red-faced septuagenarian in a peach-colored golf shirt. Everyone shakes hands. Except for some trouble with the radios (they must have a scout up there with a jammer, Jim concludes), nothing’s happened since the hamburger in­cident, so Jim regales the new­­comers with theories about where the president was when he was sup­posed to be in the National Guard. (Flying drug runs in Central America, of course: “He was a pilot.”) The gossip turns to neurotoxins, and Jim, who grew up in nearby Bisbee, tells the others how to identify the Mojave rattlesnake. “Remember, I was a Boy Scout in Cochise County,” he says, and laughs, “I never lynched one illegal Mexican the whole time.”

“Damn the bad luck!” cackles McCutchen and, as if foreseeing his words in print, glances at me ­coolly and mutters in a thick Arkansas drawl, “I’m really getting sick of hearing bigot, racist, all that.”

A little research reveals, by the by, that Joe Mc­Cutchen is not just a brutish-minded freak. De­spite an eccentric habit of writing anti-Semitic letters to his local newspapers, he is a semirespectable member of his community. He owns a small chain of pharmacies and heads a group called Protect Ar­­kansas Now, which ho­pes to float a clone of Arizona’s Prop­osition 200 for Ar­kansas voters soon. He very well may win.


What Hunter Thompson once wrote of a completely different constituency of unpleasant men ap­plies equally well to the Minutemen: “They are not all vicious drunks, and not all mental defectives either. Some are genuinely confused and frightened at what seems to be the End of the World as they know it. And this is sad, too…” Sad not only because they are scared and broken men, and painful to be around, but because their anger, anxiety and grief seem to be the flavors of the day, and trebly hard to bear for that. And sad because while they are delusional about many things and wrong about most—the majority of un­documented immigrants, it should be said, do pay taxes, and as a group put more money into the economy in taxes than they take out in services—they do have some things right.

The good union jobs for which the American working class fought for so many years are largely gone. The stable white-collar work world is no longer at all stable. And the responsibility lies with decades of decisions made by the Minutemen’s heroes (Reagan) and antiheroes (Clinton, the current Bush) alike, and most of all with the corporate powers those men so loyally served. The Minutemen were sold a dream, a newsreel fantasy of a na­tion undivided and strong (need I say white?), in which work equals pride, class doesn’t matter, and we can all sleep soundly knowing someone’s got our back.

They cannot admit that they were conned. Somebody ran off with the goods. And the only ­people around to take the blame are the ones already on their knees picking lettuce, pruning hedges, scrubbing toilets and floors, many of whom were pushed to risk their lives crossing the border by the same global economic forces that brought the Minutemen down to guard that overburdened length of wire.

In the end, the vast majority of Simcox and Gilchrist’s followers are spared the discomfort of confront­ing their fears, except from afar through the lenses of their binoculars. At the end of the month, the Minutemen claim that their calls to the Border Patrol resulted in the apprehension of 335 migrants. (They will later claim that their presence prevented the entrance of no fewer than 60,000 others.) They have not, as many people feared they would, shot anybody or even held anyone against their will. This record of nonconfrontation is spotted by only one brief en­counter that was, in its giddy, tragicomic way, characteristic of the effort as a whole. A gangly twenty-four-year-old Minuteman named Bryan Barton spotted a twenty-six-year-old migrant from Mexico named José Antonio Aboytes Sepúlveda wandering on the side of the highway. Aboytes had lost his sister and girlfriend in the desert, and had been walking alone for two days. As a friend video­taped the encounter, Barton fed Aboytes cereal, and gave him a $20 bill and a T-shirt reading “Bryan Barton caught me crossing the border and all I got was this lousy T-shirt.” Then he turned him over to Border Patrol, who dropped him unceremoniously back across the line. Neither the Border Patrol nor the Mexican consulate were able to discover what had become of Aboyte’s sister and girlfriend.


The southernmost row of headstones is not two hundred yards from the border wall and barely a hundred from an awning under which a Border Patrol truck sits idling. Here, in the Douglas Cemetery, near the center of town, the wall is only slightly more intimidating than an ordinary fence: just high steel posts, tightly spaced and ­painted beige. If you look close, you can see weld scars where the fence has been cut away and repaired, and repaired again. Even from this distance, you can see into the backyards of the homes on the other side, in Mexico, just a few feet from the wall.

When the corpses of migrants found in Cochise County can be identified, as is usually the case, the coroner turns them over to the Mexican consul in Douglas, who arranges for their repatriation. If they cannot, and it cannot even be determined that they are citizens of Mexico, the coroner delivers the remains to the funeral home just across the way from the cemetery, and they are interred here. Small birds chase each other from grave to grave. Butterflies flit among bright artificial roses. If you walk through the cedar-lined alleys, past sturdy marble headstones and crosses of wrought iron and modest wood, at the northern edge of the graveyard, you will find a cluster of low stone slabs reading either “Unidentified Male” or “Unidentified Female.” Fifteen have been buried in this red dirt since 2002. They are what is missing from this story and from the stories the Minutemen tell themselves.

Lettuce is cheap. Hotel rooms are clean. All over America, lawns are trim and magically green. Grown men lie shaking in their beds. Not everyone makes it.

More Reads

Carnivores Capitalsts and the Meat We Read

Jon Mooallem

The Secret Handshake

Samantha Hunt

The Limits of Empathy

B. Kite