An excerpt from Ross Simonini’s conversation with Jesse Eisenberg, a guest on this month’s OrganistRead the full conversation on McSweeney’s.

ROSS SIMONINI: How long have you been writing short humor pieces?

JESSE EISENBERG: Well, I recently went back home to my parents’ house and I was looking through my drawers, cleaning stuff out, and I found a lot of old jokes I wrote when I was probably—starting at 13, 14. I wrote jokes on Post-It notes and I would save them. They were all about sex, a subject of which I knew nothing about at the time but felt confident enough to make a lot of jokes about.

SIMONINI: Do you remember what any of them were?

EISENBERG: Well, they all started out generally with “I just had so much sex!” You know, the most inappropriate setup for a 13-year-old boy to write about. And some of them were funny. I think I was inspired by Borscht Belt humor, really cheesy one-liner jokes that I liked but that were not appropriate for me to be writing.

SIMONINI: And have you just been writing humor since then?

EISENBERG: I stopped to start writing plays that were more dramatically resonant, rather than just jokes—and that was very helpful in terms of writing humor, ‘cause now when I write pieces that are funny, they’re all character-based, they’re not line-based. There’s usually an undercurrent of some kind of sadness. And I don’t think I would’ve been able to do that if I didn’t stop writing things that were explicitly funny to write more dramatic plays.

Hear Jesse Eisenberg reading a short radio drama written by Ben Greenman on the latest Organist.

More Reads

Believer Radio

Claire Mullen

An Interview with Kevin Wilson

Vendela Vida

The Real Horror of Night in the Woods

Ellie Kovach